Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
I want to toss Mike D's name into the consideration, if for no reason than he was the first to swing my way. Looking back, his theory is well crafted and probably led a few of the voters my way, and I make for a relatively easy target with this group. Otherwise, I do not trust quiet people, and he has been very quiet this game. This vote is by no means locked in, but as I said, I think we should at least take a look his way and turn over a rock or two.
Sorry y'all this weekend has been crazy. Friends in from home, Desaparacidos last night, etc.
That being said, I think the overall quiet nature of this game has me stumped. I'm okay with having a LD/Boneroo runoff, but if we're being honest I'd rather viking in that runoff instead of LD.
I am not sure which way I want to go. I find it strange that we are into round 3 and no one has really called for the inspector to come out if he/she is alive and no one has really given much thought/conversation to the whack. Is everyone that sure that we have at least one mafia down? Last round NBF voted for Boneroo, SFA, and Quacker. She had a vote on Boneroo in round one as well, followed by votes for me and bacon, then hakunah. Considering she had been one of the last votes on Hakunah and Quacker, if either (or possibly both) were mafia I can see why she was whacked. I am a little leery of EAP letting Quacker die instead of extending the runoff when SFA changed, as her or Boneroo were the only ones who could have done so, and SFA for switching. Although it wasn't a last minute switch, I could see SFA paired with EAP or Boneroo and knowing they could kill quacker with a far less chance of extending the runoff. I think SFA should be considered for the runoff
Sorry y'all this weekend has been crazy. Friends in from home, Desaparacidos last night, etc.
That being said, I think the overall quiet nature of this game has me stumped. I'm okay with having a LD/Boneroo runoff, but if we're being honest I'd rather viking in that runoff instead of LD.
mc >>> LD
Then why didn't you vote for Viking instead of me?
This is by far the most bizarre game of mafia I have played. SFA, are you alive man? I have no idea if we are on track or not, but I have to believe we got at least 1 mafia member in quacker. In addition to everything I pointed out prior to his lynch, both whacks point to him.
As far as Mike D and my vote from him, as I said, I really only voted for him because he was quiet and voted for me. I am going to check back later and will probably change my vote once SFA comes on and says his piece.
LD if anyone else agreed on my suspicions of Viking or voted for him I probably would've, but it seems like he's been cleared for at least this round. Once this round is over and we know whether or not we were wrong about any of our choices, I think we'll have a bit more to think about.
Well, between the two in the runoff, I am much more suspicious of LD. First he keeps trying to get people to target me. Like LD, I am a relatively easy target, because of past events and issues with certain players. However, when the same thing happens to him, he can't believe it is happening. I ma always more inclined to give LD the benefit of the doubt because I know what it feels like to be targeted, but it bit me in the @ss before too. Add to that his lurking early on while posting elsewhere on the board, and I feel LD is more suspicious than Boneroo.
I've been in the hospital since noon on Thuesday. I can get a mod to back me up on that if need be. Haven't signed in or seen the game. I'm really drugged up at the moment. Just got home. Let me settle in and I'll be back soon to give my opinion on stuff.
Sorry I missed a vote. I've played for over two years and that's never happened. It was beyond my control.
I've been in the hospital since noon on Thuesday. I can get a mod to back me up on that if need be. Haven't signed in or seen the game. I'm really drugged up at the moment. Just got home. Let me settle in and I'll be back soon to give my opinion on stuff.
Sorry I missed a vote. I've played for over two years and that's never happened. It was beyond my control.
What's confussing about it. Viking was getting stacked on? I was already wanting to get the possible runoff canidates switched up. So I went with the person going after Viking the most. AND in hindsight, NBF got whacked.
but IMO sfa and viking are also suspicious. i am not a fan of the fact that bacon made such a point to vote for him, nor that sfa changed his vote off NBF after seemingly trying to make others change their vote.
so i am open to change.
Again, NBF was the next whacked player, so we should be going after the names she was saying. Which I know points at me but I can tell you I'm not mafia.
I'd go LD over Boneroo, just based on what Bacon said. Still haven't had time to look over NBF's post, which could mean she was indeed inspector and was trying to lead us to Boneroo.
I have a feeling we've got one mafia down or one in the runoff. Still catching up.
I would normally agree with you except LD has been trying to kill me all game and the last time he did that, he was mafia. I tried to get people to take a look at Mike D and no one was talking. I really do not see what Boneroo has done wrong this game except be new. With him, I agree on the mafia targeting him. So between one guy I would probably put in the townie column, and another I am less sure of, I chose LD.
I would normally agree with you except LD has been trying to kill me all game and the last time he did that, he was mafia. I tried to get people to take a look at Mike D and no one was talking. I really do not see what Boneroo has done wrong this game except be new. With him, I agree on the mafia targeting him. So between one guy I would probably put in the townie column, and another I am less sure of, I chose LD.
Has anyone heard from Mike D?
Way to spew a bunch of shit. How many times have I voted for you in this game? Like, once - in the 2nd round?
Could you and Quacker have been coaching Boneroo to not fuck up this game?
I wish I had some coaching here, cuz. I'm pretty lost on who could be, or could have been mafia. I'm not gonna try to save my ass here, but if I am run off, I hope we've eliminated at-least one mafia prior to this round, otherwise the game could be over here.
Neither of these two really jump out at me, but looking at the votes of those who I already find suspicious and the whacks, I feel Boneroo is far more likely to be mafia.
Boneroo, if we have not gotten one mafia yet, the game IS over. LD, what I posted is not shiz. Boneroo has been targeted because he is new and easy to target. You on the other hand, have been given an enormous amount of slack because of your previous game play, and previous mafia targeting, which you have used to come out of the shadows and attack me at the beginning of the last runoff. Then you wanted people to switch to me this round as well.
The only known to me this game is that I am a townie, but I am betting Boneroo is either being set up with both whacks pointing to him, or is playing the best first game in mafia I have seen yet. And THAT would mean he has great coaching behind him, which means we are all fucked anyways. Hence, my vote for you. If no one else sees it this way and changes, then fine, but I would rather take my chances this way. I realize this makes me a target in Day 4, but it has long been said that one day our defense of LD will bite us in the end. Take this for what is is worth, but I think LD is the bigger threat.
Boneroo, if we have not gotten one mafia yet, the game IS over. LD, what I posted is not shiz. Boneroo has been targeted because he is new and easy to target. You on the other hand, have been given an enormous amount of slack because of your previous game play, and previous mafia targeting, which you have used to come out of the shadows and attack me at the beginning of the last runoff. Then you wanted people to switch to me this round as well.
The only known to me this game is that I am a townie, but I am betting Boneroo is either being set up with both whacks pointing to him, or is playing the best first game in mafia I have seen yet. And THAT would mean he has great coaching behind him, which means we are all quacked anyways. Hence, my vote for you. If no one else sees it this way and changes, then fine, but I would rather take my chances this way. I realize this makes me a target in Day 4, but it has long been said that one day our defense of LD will bite us in the end. Take this for what is is worth, but I think LD is the bigger threat.
But you have no proof that I am Mafia. For someone who researches and studies this game as much as you do, you're really just grasping at straws. What the Mafia has done, it really doesn't set me up or pin me as Mafia. And I'd really like for you to try and prove otherwise.
It is impossible to prove anything in this game as you have seen many times. And as I said, I think you are a bigger threat and that Boneroo is a bigger target. That means I believe it is more likely that you are mafia over Boneroo, but not necessarily mafia. If you look back, I voted Mike D and not you in Day 3 prior to the runoff, since I believe there were much more likely candidates then you. However, no one else was talking, and we are where we are right now. What I am trying to say is that you are a bigger threat if you ARE mafia, since you have a lot of experience in the game, so I can't make the case that you actually are mafia. You are also just more suspicious to me since you have pushed several times for people to kill me.
That is not grasping at straws, that is playing the hand I am dealt. I wish we had a different runoff, but this is what we have so, my vote is going to remain on you, and I am going to explain why I am voting that way, since that helps the townies.
In the second round runoff I made the final vote(a switch off of NBF) at 2:08pm. Jimmyroo closed the round at 8:45 that night. Not a single player tried to force a second runoff. Which leads me to belive that I was right saying the mafia was fine with the way that runoff was shaping up to begin with.
These are the non-quacker voters at the time....
EAP >> Viking >> NBF Boneroo >> NBF
LD >> Viking Quacker >> Viking
EAP is the only one to even call my vote switch into question, so lets give her the benefit of the doubt for now. I'd say the odds are either Boneroo or LD are mafia. And they were sitting back not wanting to rock the boat. Now we have to figure out which one.
So going off of past games, we can assume mafia have split their votes. Assuming neither Hakuna or quacker were mafia, these tallys will tell us a lot more IF we get another round. Pay attention to this Quacker vote off for sure.
And if you look at the bottom of page 7, you will see several of us talking about how quite it had been and maybe the mafia was fine with quacker, NBF and Viking going into the runoff. So we can possible mark viking off the list as well.
Last Edit: Feb 27, 2013 0:17:44 GMT -5 by Deleted - Back to Top
The only problem is that it has to be one or the other and if we did not get a mafia member already, then we are fucked, since the mafia would not taken two members into a runoff this late in the game if they could avoid it. No effort was made to avoid it. So which one is the mafia member and which one is the target? This is the inherent conundrum.
The only problem is that it has to be one or the other and if we did not get a mafia member already, then we are quacked, since the mafia would not taken two members into a runoff this late in the game if they could avoid it. No effort was made to avoid it. So which one is the mafia member and which one is the target? This is the inherent conundrum.
That's one of the reasons I wanted Mike D to have the last vote.
Who was targeted the most at the beginning of the second round? And which one of them voted for you?
Edit: Sorry for all the edits. I'm pilled up but feeling better.
Last Edit: Feb 27, 2013 0:33:23 GMT -5 by Deleted - Back to Top