Post by superfurryanimal on Jun 25, 2012 21:49:44 GMT -5
This might be the biggest mess of a game I've ever played in. Just reading over the game so many theorys pop into my head but I can't make heads or tales of them.
I don't understand why EAP asked for the inspector to come forward so many times and then was willing to put players she was unsure about into the runoff. Was she really going to try and risk making it another round? The same goes with Mike but I kind of believe he would be more willing to take that risk.
The mafia whacks don't really make sense with either of them as inspector. I could argue why both of them should be dead know.
I'm not really sure what we should do here. It almost seems that we have to have at least one mafia dead. I'd almost say we let both of them live and see who gets whacked.
Now that both of them have said I'm innocent, I would be very surprised if I made it to the last round. So we have a situation where Bacon is most likely going to be there. So to the very end we arn't going to know if we can trust him or not. Part of me feels that everyone should vote me off. Just to force the mafia to kill a player they had planed to use to shift guilt towards.
If we decide to keep both "inspectors" alive are choices are: bacon Nic quacker LLL
Sense the mafia tend to be able to keep at least one of their players out of the runoffs I'd say we make it between Nic and quacker.
This is just an idea and I know it's not perfect. At this point it's a shot in the dark either way.
All we know for sure is that whoever is faking inspector isn't alone. We have at least 2 mafia left. And a slight chance of a third, depending on who is telling the truth.
Also, if VIking is Mafia with Kdogg he should be banned for pulling the "tell a mod" bullhonkey.
I have been out and not really on inforoo again until yesterday, but to clear this up, I asked Adam to remove a post that had the potential to harm my ability to do business in real life. You all know I take this game very seriously when I play, but potentially affecting someone's ability to do business in real life crosses my own personal line. Fawn said it best: PMs are private, and earlier in the game I almost violated that about the game, but he violated that with a string I specifically asked to keep private.
Anything else is fair game.
Obviously, KDogg is going through his own issues right now, and I wish him the best, but I was extremely angry that evening, hence telling a mod and not even logging in for a week. Just wanted to clear that up.
Post by LoveLuckLaughter on Jun 26, 2012 10:30:58 GMT -5
Like I said Viking, if you turn out to be Mafia, I feel like that was just a way for you to quack up the game, as you like to do. Therefore if you turn out to be Mafia, I don't believe your above stated reasoning--especially based on what was in the PM (which I saw before it was taken down). If you're not Mafia, I believe it.
Thankfully I have no bearing on your life, so you probably shouldn't care too much if I believe you or not.
Post by LoveLuckLaughter on Jun 26, 2012 11:02:14 GMT -5
If Mike D is Mafia faking Inspector, I think his partners are Bacon, Quacker or Nic
If EAP is Mafia faking Inspector, I think it is Kdogg and you or Nic. So picking you or Nic is a win-win in my opinion.
This is the best I can do for right now until I decide which side I'm going to believe. Unfortunately we don't have the time to whittle away a little at both sides, we are too far in the game. Or else I would vote them both off.
Post by LoveLuckLaughter on Jun 26, 2012 16:09:12 GMT -5
Maybe. The only chance we are taking is that if there are 3 Mafia, we lose. But shit, at least we'd be killing ourselves. I'd rather kill ourselves than let the Mafia get the best of us. We have just as much of a chance doing this as we do killing you or Mike. D. And a better chance if there are only two Mafia left. We may even get lucky and pick the third Mafia name.
Post by superfurryanimal on Jun 26, 2012 16:13:30 GMT -5
I agree with LLL.
Here is what I can tell. Both "Inspectors" say I'm innocent AND I AM. Which means I'm in their plans to be whacked either night 3 or 4. They are going to keep people alive that they have made or the townies see as suspicious.
If we keep both of them alive, the mafia has to kill the real inspector. Or risk keeping them alive and having them reveal another innocent/mafia member. If neither inspector is whacked voting off Bacon makes the most sense. Because if Mike is lying Bacon will make it to the next round and noone will know if they can trust him or not.
Or we could vote off Nic, Quacker, or LLL. The problem with this is we don't really get as much information voting off the unknowns. We know a lot of players think it could be LLL. I don't see that at all. I think LLL is going to be kept around until the end to be set up. Possible to allow Bacon to make it to the end.
IF Mike is telling the truth then EAP probable only has one mafia alley left alive with her. Maybe Quacker or LLL or Nic as the long shot. She seems to be harder to place with any living players.
Mike is the only one of the two that could be faking with two mafia members alive with him. Some mix of Mike, Quacker, Bacon or Nic. I don't see LLL working with Mike here.
So I think we vote of Bacon and force the mafia's hand. OR we vote of me or LLL and make them give up more information with their night 4 whack.
Post by superfurryanimal on Jun 26, 2012 16:20:50 GMT -5
I meant Bacon will make it to the last round. Best to get the possible sleeper agent out of the way and force the mafia to regroup. Everyone think on this. This is probably the best way to go. At least it gives the townies a fighting chance and forces the mafia to make more revealing moves then us just voting blindly.
Dude, round one and two told us nothing. We have nothing to go on and reading over the tread I can't find a single reliable fact besides you and EAP saying I'm innocent.
At least this way we force the mafia into some sort of action instead of just blindly hoping we find them. And like I've said, the odds are you would be the one to have two other mafia players alive with you. At least we will get some reliable information this way.