I'm convinced Phi is Mafia, or a really really confused Townsperson (kind of like me with RDK last game). I was convinced he was Mafia and he turned out to be a Townie. For now, until I have more time to re-re-re-read this thread, lol.
Damn you "No editing" rule!!! I also want to add that my vote could change. I'd like to hear from the more quiet participants. RDK, KK, .... any insight? Typically the quieter the player, the more likely they are Mafia.
can someone research who rdk and fawn were on to so we can figure out the mafia? i'm only on here for 5 min and gotta run, kthxbye
for now. im still convinced.......
Phi >>> Duddits
As for RDK, IDK who he was on to? I mention him earlier for vote stacking, but backed off. Mafia saw what I did, in Omar. IDK about rdk, but I think we know the answer to the other part of that question, In FM last post she mentioned Scrog playing Mafia brilliantly. So I would say she was on to me, she mentioned my posting of thoughts and being "informative and controlled", and they have and I can say I have held back. Look at last game. I am trying not to 'bully'. but I would not have whacked her. She mentions me as Mafia, then I kill her? Who is gonna be looked at as Mafia? Me! Look at the post before, even though this is "Captain" FM speaking, I think townies should take note.
This is your captain speaking, oh no i mean my captain. Captain and diet that is. (No i am not suggesting i'm the inspector, i'm not.) A little friday cocktail humor. Maybe I'll think differently in the morning...
But staring at this now and the delay in votes, can't help but wonder if either Bonz or Duddits is mafia, and either LD or Phi is mafia, and one of the hold out voters are hoping to save a mafia peep. ???
If I am reading this right, FawnMart's 3 combos:
1. Bonz or Duddits 2. Phi or LD 3. late voter.
1. I changed my vote for Bonzai and I think for good reason. Her lack of "fight" makes me feel better in that decision. If I was being voted off or "set up", I would be raising hell. IDK, then again I might not play like everyone else. I think she was Mafia.
2. Phi, I may have been wrong on you, I was saying early in the game you were not Mafia, but now I am thinking I might be wrong.
3. Phi were you not a late voter?
Phi I see you in two of those groups, it works out good for you, the one who started the Scrog style of posting thought,
Honestly? It's just the way he words his posts in this thread. They seem methodical and thought out.
Townies, I ask you to think about this. Phi wants me in a run-off, FM bites and asks, why? Phi says I am, "methodical and thought out". Later on FM repeats that I am posting that way, then you whack her, so it looks like I did it. nice, implant the idea, when that player repeats the idea, whack that player and draw attention to the one the idea is about. Then you come out and ask, "can someone research who rdk and fawn were on to, so we can figure out the mafia?". Come on, you know the answer to that! but, why rdk anyway? on the surface, it is obvious who FM was onto. You are the one who first mentioned that thought/idea, that Scrog is Mafia because of his "well thought out, informative, new playing style". or what ever you want to call it. Maybe I am feeling threatened and paranoid and connecting things that are not there, but Phi, last game you mentioned thinking on 2nd and 3rd levels, well that move is differently a 3rd level move!
Post by krunchykat on Jan 10, 2012 18:06:35 GMT -5
I think it's time to read through this thread yet again. I have a couple of theories I need to work out. If bonzai wasn't mafia, which she may not have been since she was voted off so easily, then I think all three mafia are still alive. If so we need to get our shit together now or else it's game over.
Inspector, IF you're still with us now is the time to come out. If any of you mafia twerps even think about coming out as fake inspector this game I swear I'll hang you from the clock tower by your fucking underwear when I see you at Roo.
Post by ntellier85 on Jan 10, 2012 22:52:23 GMT -5
ok back in nashville so can pay more attention to this thread. i am sold Duddits is mafia. I know I am a townie so the fact that he is calling me out as mafia as soon as i vote for him seals the deal for me. i certainly understand why i am under suspicion right now with the rest of you since ive been quiet lately, but once again, I AM A TOWNIE!
Ok, I got interrupted while reading back through the thread earlier and I'm just now getting done. I fucking hate being the last to vote but it seems to happen that way every time I play this game. I guess it's my schedule since it's hard for me to be on here in the evenings.
I know I'm a townie. My thoughts are that either abra or rdk are mafia because both have been really quiet and not said much about how they vote or what they're thinking. As for Phi, Duddits and LD, I know there have to be 2 mafia members in this group. They have all done a lot of finger pointing and arguing with each other throughout the game. My thoughts are that the two mafia members have intentionally made it look as if they are working against each other to separate themselves. My guess here is that it's Phi and LD.
If you look at the bek voters in round one that are still alive you have
Abra and LD came back at the last minute to change their votes and took out bek.
And who is voting together for Duddits this round? That would be Phi, LD and rdk.
Just some food for thought for the townies. Could I be missing something? Maybe. But I think I'm at least pretty damn close on my reasoning here.
Sorry Phi, I'm not even going to consider changing anything until I hear from everyone else.
Also, since we've not heard from our inspector yet I'm pretty sure she's dead. Honestly now that I think about it, I believe our inspector may have been bek. It could have been Omar, but we may have killed our own inspector.