Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Im still not sure how to judge these guys. I personally just dont care for the music but I dont think its bad. I think the review has good points but does come off bitter and immature. A 1.6 should be something that is musically unbearable, not for a band you idealogically disagree with.
I liked them before I listened to this album. It's terrible.
I've tried 3 times but I've never once been able to make it through this entire review; its gibberish
Those are the best ones though. When it feels like the writer is discussing anything else besides the album they're theoretically reviewing. The Kid A review a the famous example of that.
Or when they just straight up didn't give the album the time of day like Partie Traumatic. I placed a heavy value on Pitchfork's opinion at that time in my life and opening this review was a hilarious shock
I've tried 3 times but I've never once been able to make it through this entire review; its gibberish
Those are the best ones though. When it feels like the writer is discussing anything else besides the album they're theoretically reviewing. The Kid A review a the famous example of that.
Or when they just straight up didn't give the album the time of day like Partie Traumatic. I placed a heavy value on Pitchfork's opinion at that time in my life and opening this review was a hilarious shock
Those are the best ones though. When it feels like the writer is discussing anything else besides the album they're theoretically reviewing. The Kid A review a the famous example of that.
Or when they just straight up didn't give the album the time of day like Partie Traumatic. I placed a heavy value on Pitchfork's opinion at that time in my life and opening this review was a hilarious shock
Now that I'm thinking about it, the first Jet review is way better than the video of the pissing monkey. And it's fairly relevant to the GvF discussion pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/4338-get-born/
Post by snowmanomura on Oct 24, 2018 10:52:48 GMT -5
Roo has already booked Lez Zeppelin, Bustle in Your hedgerow, and John Paul Jones throughout the years. I'd rather seem someone more talented play actual zeppelin tunes than the banal GvF imitation.
Roo has already booked Lez Zeppelin, Bustle in Your hedgerow, and John Paul Jones throughout the years. I'd rather seem someone more talented play actual zeppelin tunes than the banal GvF imitation.
Well too bad, cos they are selling like hot cakes and Bonnaroo is in fact the cold calculating machine of your nightmares!
I'd rather seem someone more talented play actual zeppelin tunes than the banal GvF imitation.
Have you seen them live? They kick ass.
Feel like this GvF-LZ thing is turning into a "Say, the line Bart"-meme. We get it.
I've seen bands in bars around the country who play better than they play. It's not impressive. The songs make a band impressive, and they just don't have the songs.
I'd rather seem someone more talented play actual zeppelin tunes than the banal GvF imitation.
Have you seen them live? They kick ass.
Feel like this GvF-LZ thing is turning into a "Say, the line Bart"-meme. We get it.
Yeah. They didn't suck live at ACL. I'm not going to listen to their albums, but I'll sometimes watch their performances. It's entertaining, and at least they rock which is more than can be said for about 65% of festival acts these days unless you're at a specific rock or metal fest.
Feel like this GvF-LZ thing is turning into a "Say, the line Bart"-meme. We get it.
I've seen bands in bars around the country who play better than they play. It's not impressive. The songs make a band impressive, and they just don't have the songs.
My opinion, of course.
Keep in mind that they're still only all around 20 years old. Can't imagine a band in a bar playing that is younger (or their age) playing a lot better than them. I'm not an expert in guitarplay (or whatever instrument you're playing) but I do think they can grow a lot in the coming years.
Feel like this GvF-LZ thing is turning into a "Say, the line Bart"-meme. We get it.
I've seen bands in bars around the country who play better than they play. It's not impressive. The songs make a band impressive, and they just don't have the songs.
My opinion, of course.
I did enjoy GVF when I saw them live. But when you actually listen to this album you hear a lot more cringeworthy shit. Live it's just fun. But you're right, lots of bands do Zep better than they do.
I've seen bands in bars around the country who play better than they play. It's not impressive. The songs make a band impressive, and they just don't have the songs.
My opinion, of course.
Keep in mind that they're still only all around 20 years old. Can't imagine a band in a bar playing that is younger (or their age) playing a lot better than them. I'm not an expert in guitarplay (or whatever instrument you're playing) but I do think they can grow a lot in the coming years.
I'm not gonna comment on their playing because I'm no expert. They seem like they know their way around their instruments, and maybe they'll grow as a band. We will see! It's all (imo) going to rely on their ability to develop their sound and songwriting.
They are fine at their instruments, they have okay songs, they are just such a rip off. It would be like if someone painted the mona lisa but not quite as good and people lost it saying that whatever genre of art the mona lisa is is back
I've seen bands in bars around the country who play better than they play. It's not impressive. The songs make a band impressive, and they just don't have the songs.
My opinion, of course.
I did enjoy GVF when I saw them live. But when you actually listen to this album you hear a lot more cringeworthy shit. Live it's just fun. But you're right, lots of bands do Zep better than they do.
This. I watched their Lolla set and they seem like something that wouldn't be horrible to spend time at if there was nothing else on my schedule.
I also love that I have no idea what Bing is going to like and what he's not. Haha. Way to go man, surprising us all (assuming I'm not the only one).
I also love that I have no idea what Bing is going to like and what he's not. Haha. Way to go man, surprising us all (assuming I'm not the only one).
What do you mean? I really like their music but objectively I've to agree on certain spots that that reviewer of Pitchfork touches on in his "review". I'm a fan of Post Malone and even dig a lot of Twenty One Pilots but a lot of people hate both on here and that's fine. Everyone has their own taste. I'm not gonna pretend both are dropping the most cutting edge content with only lyrical highlights in their songs (same goes to GvF). For that shit I'll listen to something else.
I also love that I have no idea what Bing is going to like and what he's not. Haha. Way to go man, surprising us all (assuming I'm not the only one).
What do you mean? I really like their music but objectively I've to agree on certain spots that that reviewer of Pitchfork touches on in his "review". I'm a fan of Post Malone and even dig a lot of Twenty One Pilots but a lot of people hate both on here and that's fine. Everyone has their own taste. I'm not gonna pretend both are dropping the most cutting edge content with only lyrical highlights in their songs (same goes to GvF). For that shit I'll listen to something else.
I was just complimenting you on your diverse taste in music. I wish I was more diverse and not so in my bubble.
I've seen bands in bars around the country who play better than they play. It's not impressive. The songs make a band impressive, and they just don't have the songs.
My opinion, of course.
Keep in mind that they're still only all around 20 years old. Can't imagine a band in a bar playing that is younger (or their age) playing a lot better than them. I'm not an expert in guitarplay (or whatever instrument you're playing) but I do think they can grow a lot in the coming years.
Both Robert Plant and John Bonham were only 21 when Led Zeppelin II came out