So you seem to be advocating for vote switches now rather than letting a second runoff possibly root out Mafia by forcing them to defend up to two players? Interesting. I am not usually a proponent of 3 person runoffs but I think one, maybe two are Mafia here. If that is the decision that is made, I will be switching to Mike d.
I'm not really advocating either. Just pointing out that which ever route we go will end up with the same need for vote switches because no one is going to let me just vote someone off, obviously. I'm fine with the people we have in contention at the moment. If you are fine going in than I won't try to stop you.
It seems like we have a majority that feels this is a good selection and that at least one mafia is surly in this group. For now, I'll make a place holder vote and we shall see what happens.
I'll vote Noage, just to get off of null. If people start flipping votes around, I'm likely to change. I'm only voting him because people seem content with this runoff.
Its all good, I did confuse me though when I saw that
SFA - looking back I did leave a comment/question to me unanswered as to why I suspect you as mafia. I was basing that off of comments that other folks have made in games where you go along and side with/befriend townies so well when you are mafia. From my perspective I saw that, but realized that I was the one remove you from the runoff in round 1 prior to that, but you still seem on the more calm and collected side of things this game. I don't know if that would discount that thought train or not though. I have voiced that I am most suspicious of LLL. In addition, I dread the game that the two of you are mafia together (and i'm not the third) and realized since I posted it that a big part of me calling you out was a fear of this being that game. To sum it up SFA - you scare the shit out of me in this game
SFA - looking back I did leave a comment/question to me unanswered as to why I suspect you as mafia. I was basing that off of comments that other folks have made in games where you go along and side with/befriend townies so well when you are mafia.
I don't really see this as a strategy, it's just how I play no matter my role. I can think of two games where I made an effort to "befriend" someone and that was with Bonnie(When I was mafia with you) and Jhamm(when I was mafia with EAP) but both of those instances had outside circumstances, that made them a viable strategy. AND the reason they worked is because they are already apart of the way I play the game. Which is to be a devils advocate and stick up for people. Which I've done in pretty much every game I've played, to some degree.
But as for this game I don't feel I've done that in any manner that shows a possible hidden agenda. Probably because I don't have one????
From my perspective I saw that, but realized that I was the one remove you from the runoff in round 1 prior to that, but you still seem on the more calm and collected side of things this game. I don't know if that would discount that thought train or not though. I have voiced that I am most suspicious of LLL. In addition, I dread the game that the two of you are mafia together (and i'm not the third) and realized since I posted it that a big part of me calling you out was a fear of this being that game.
Yeah, and I returned the favor because at the time I couldn't think of a reason a mafia member would save me but I wasn't really thinking about you doing for your own self preservation.
I don't understand what you mean by I'm more calm and collective? I have mood swings no matter what my role is. I was fairly pissy near the end of the second round.
If LLL and I were mafia together don't you think the whacks would have been a lot different? Both of our names have been brought up a bunch this game. She might be but I know I'm not. And YES PLEASE. We've only been waiting almost two years to finally be mafia together. Alas, the only time it happened the game had to be reset.
To sum it up SFA - you scare the shiz out of me in this game
You said this once before and I wasn't mafia then either.
Edit: coding error....
Last Edit: Oct 3, 2012 3:06:49 GMT -5 by superfurryanimal - Back to Top
Post by superfurryanimal on Oct 3, 2012 9:13:49 GMT -5
I'm going to vote to the best of my abilities but feel free to shake things up while we can. We don't really have any damning information and reading over there are so many inconsistencies that's it's hard to make any ties.
EAP - At first(this round) I felt sure that EAP was innocent and I still kinda feel that way. It's weird that she hasn't said anything sense the runoff began or much before it. And there are the mafia whack ties that we have all already discussed. I guess I'm a little concerned about several people are saying they don't think she's guilty and she's being set up. I just don't see the mafia using their early round whacks purely to set people up. So I'm a leery of that defense but sense she hasn't made it herself then their really isn't much to blame her for.
LLL- I will go into detail if someone asks but our voting history made me feel fairly indifferent to her putting me in a first round runoff. As far as her playing, it's hard to tell. The mafia whacks don't really lead to her. My main problem is her trying to connect me with Mike. I'm also use to the mafia trying to set the two of us up, which has already been discussed. It's happened so many times. I'm also well aware of her tricks an haven't read her wrong sense she first made a fool of me in this game.
Mike D - The first round business has been discussed. My main problem with Mike is he keeps saying he thinks I'm mafia based on no real evidence of what I've done in the game. I mean it's pretty common for players to make their points with facts about playing style. What I don't understand is how wrong or (purposefully) over-stated his claims our when it comes to the game at hand.
So I don't really know what I want to do. I'm still looking over who could be mafia if we have 3 left. We are in real trouble if so. As I was trying to say last night, it doesn't seem like a 3 person runoff is going to help us narrow it down much. I would have rather of had one with LLL and Mike. Which, doing the math in my head, wouldn't be that much better, I don't reckon.
I'm going with Mike for now. Maybe this will get some people talking? Sorry my posts is a little wonky. Had some personal stuff to deal with overnight. I'll try get back around a computer by 5 or so.
What do you want me to say? I'm sorry I'm just being a shitty player this game. I shouldn't have signed up. I have nothing of substance to contribute. I post in other threads bc it requires less brain cells. Haha
I'm not mafia, believe it or don't. Our inspector is apparently dead or wouldn't let us be floundering in this way.
Post by LoveLuckLaughter on Oct 3, 2012 23:04:34 GMT -5
What prompted that Mike D?
Also, I have work and a girls night out tomorrow. I won't be participating after about 1pm. So if anyone has any points of debate or concerns that they want to discuss with me before the runoff ends, now is the time.
Shit, this is what I get for not being around enough. I hate having the deciding vote. I am going to have to go with Mike D on this one. I stated in the last page the reasons I felt EAP was innocent and I still feel that way. Sorry Mike, but:
5/28 - Purity Ring
6/2 - St. Vincent
6/6 - Cake
6/10 - Temples
6/13 - The Toadies
6/15 - Gogol Bordello
6/18 - The War On Drugs
6/26 - Surfer Blood
7/20 - Primus/Dinosaur Jr.
8/9 - Deftones/Death From Above 1979
9/29 - Alt-J