I loved both albums, with Oracular Spectacular translating better in a live music/party setting and Congratulations being the better driving in the car/chilling with some headphones album. If I had to pick one or the other I would pick Congratulations. I unfortunately missed their first show in.. 2008? I was able to catch the ending of their 2009 show because I was at NiN, and I thought the last few songs were decent enough. I was able to catch their entire show from a decent spot in 2010 at Voodoo Fest and I loved the show. I thought they were great live and left thinking it was one of my favorite shows of the weekend. It was topped off by getting a high five from Andrew when he and Ben ran through the middle of the crowd. I welcome their return and am exactly about the new album.