Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Post by popsicle sarah on Mar 7, 2012 18:18:23 GMT -5
This isn't what I expected to find when I returned from work. This thread wasn't even in the "new topics" so I thought for sure it was OVER. Damn.
I'm not sure I have the mental fortitude to try to figure this out after having my brain stuffed with info at the first 3 days of my new job.
CST - you being so sure that I'm mafia makes me think that you are. I'm not mafia. I think a townie at this point would be unsure because whichever of the two of you it is has played a darn good game. I had a strong gut feeling about you early in the game, but your responses did a pretty good job of convincing me otherwise. Maybe I should go back to my gut feeling?
EAP - if you are the last mafia then I'm super impressed because I just can't seem to wrap my brain around you being mafia.
I'm going to reread the thread as each of you being mafia and see if anything sticks out. Haven't read the first few pages in awhile so maybe fresh eyes can pick something out.
This isn't what I expected to find when I returned from work. This thread wasn't even in the "new topics" so I thought for sure it was OVER. Damn.
I'm not sure I have the mental fortitude to try to figure this out after having my brain stuffed with info at the first 3 days of my new job.
CST - you being so sure that I'm mafia makes me think that you are. I'm not mafia. I think a townie at this point would be unsure because whichever of the two of you it is has played a darn good game. I had a strong gut feeling about you early in the game, but your responses did a pretty good job of convincing me otherwise. Maybe I should go back to my gut feeling?
EAP - if you are the last mafia then I'm super impressed because I just can't seem to wrap my brain around you being mafia.
I'm going to reread the thread as each of you being mafia and see if anything sticks out. Haven't read the first few pages in awhile so maybe fresh eyes can pick something out.
I had a gut feeling about you in the beginning too, ya know. My reasoning for choosing you over EAP is the same as yours... If she is a mafia, she is damn good, didn't seem suspicious at all. And since the only other left is you... Well, that's what I went with.
I think my reasoning for choosing you on the last page was pretty solid and you've done nothing to make me think otherwise, you just pointed the finger back at me. I am actually more confident now than I was before, because you didn't explain yourself or refute any of the claims I made that made me believe you were mafia.
Post by popsicle sarah on Mar 7, 2012 18:52:03 GMT -5
OK, I'm going through the thread and some things stand out to me. Knowing that only one of you is mafia is putting a little different spin on somethings for me.
I agree that SFA faked being inspector. He did so when there was a stalemate of 3 votes each for 3 people: Nic, CST, & Scrog. In hindsight it seems like Nic was confused about being called Mafia and never really defended himself. I think he was innocent.
Faking inspector at that time was actually pure genious and I wouldn't expect anything less from SFA. With 3 votes each, when people started changing it could've gone either way. The only person in danger that could've been mafia was CST. Faking inspector made sure that CST didn't go home.
Right after SFA "came out" as inspector he called out EAP. This really makes me thing that EAP isn't mafia. If the mafia were putting all their eggs in one basket, why would they call that person out?
yeah, i don't really see a reason for SFA to come out this early as "inspector" if it wasn't true. most mafia who have played this card, wait until they are all backed against a wall and we haven't had a enough rounds for that. SFA is a good player (and even though he tricked me last time ), i think he is our inspector.
EAP>>>>nick
Pretty sure this is your third one right here.
(For the record, I'm writing this out as I read through.)
SFA called me and EAP out A LOT and said several times that there's no way CST is mafia.
I'm convinced.
Sarah >>> CST
This isn't a reciprocal vote. I'm looking for which one of you is mafia and after reading through the first couple of pages with SFA being mafia, there are so many things that point to CST.
I think my reasoning for choosing you on the last page was pretty solid and you've done nothing to make me think otherwise, you just pointed the finger back at me. I am actually more confident now than I was before, because you didn't explain yourself or refute any of the claims I made that made me believe you were mafia.
The reason I'm not going to refute any of the claims that you made is because I don't need to convince you. You already know I'm not mafia. The only person I have to convince is EAP.
And all she has to do is read the first six pages from the point of view of knowing that SFA is mafia and she will see.
I stand by my vote 100% and I'm not changing it. I'm actually pretty proud of myself for figure this out. And even though LD was not a good inspector... the fact the he came out and stayed alive til near the end is what did CST, Phi, and SFA in. I'm pretty sure they felt they had it in the bag.
Actually all SFA did was say that he was relatively certain that I was innocent, and I'm sure that was just so when the time came that we figured out SFA was a fake inspector, it would look like he was trying to save someone.
alright sorry friends. i was busy having my mind blown by radiohead.
first of all, one of you is guilty and one of you is innocent. but i kind of think you are both a little crazy. i really believe that SFA was our real inspector......i seem to be the only one that thinks that anymore. maybe i am missing something.
i have choked like this at an end of a game before and i feel like that's why i've been kept around.
that said, if i go back and look through keeping SFA as mafia (which you are right sarah, only a seasoned player like SFA could pull off something so wild and smart at the same time.), then constanza you have to be it.
Don't do it EAP! You have one last chance to save us, I beg you, believe me. Grill me in any way whatsoever. Whatever questions or suspicions you have, fire away, and I will do my best to convince you that I am a townie, because I 100% am! Don't let the sweet little kitten in her avatar fool you, as far as this game is concerned, Sarah is pure evil!
to be honest, i'm still not buying the whole SFA wasn't inspector thing. if i am were to, my only problem is that SFA kept saying over and over again you were "probably innocent" and that sarah and i were wildcards. why would he be so sure about you and not us so early on??
i'm going to have to keep my vote as is.
UGH. seriously townies please don't hate me if i blow it.
Well, I tried. As I said before, I think SFA was just trying to make it look like he was protecting someone were we to figure out he wasn't the real inspector. I'm not sure what else I can say at this point to convince you. Sarah has played this game excellently you are the last mafia and at this point it's basically just her word against mine.
Post by popsicle sarah on Mar 8, 2012 19:37:33 GMT -5
I just spent nearly an hour and a half in my own hell (dark + rain + rush hour). The same drive during morning rush hour in the rain took 35 minutes.
Anyways...
I'm not changing my vote.
I have a slight bit of doubt that I may be wrong. EAP, if it turns out you are mafia, I will nominate you as Mafia Player of the Year. The only reason I have doubt is that you've played so many games as a townie that I think it would be pretty effortless for you to play as a townie if you were mafia. I can't find anything that points to you and trust me I've looked.
So, my vote stands. CST - if I'm wrong and it is EAP, well I'm sorry. At least we'd both be wrong We can apologize to the rest of the townies together.
Alright Fawn, lay it on us. I'll have that wincing, covering my eyes and peeking through my fingers look when I see you post next.
EAP for Mafia Goddess The way you had CST and I so sure of each other was amazing.
I bow to the goddess of Mafia! EAP played day 4 and 5 flawlessly!! She knows i wanted the townies to win and also knows I conceded last night that she was almost certainly going to rule it this game!
It is so challenging reffing and keeping quiet! You get PM's that you can not respond to but want to scream YES!! YES -- you got em'.. townies will win.. And then, sigh, it all changes, and you must stay neutral.
Off to change the thread title. Who's the next ref??
Oh- and many thanks to NoAge for covering the dark-o'clock hours for me. Much appreciated!!
Seriously LD, Why did you do that? You confused everyone and made people ignore the actual inspector. I told you guys to vote off EAP after Phi!
I can't believe the townies lost this but I'm to blame as well. EAP made me second guess myself although I had already named all three mafia to Fawn early on. Good job EAP. I also overlooked a reply Sarah made to me. If I had of seen that and responded maybe I could have clarified why I was so sure of it being either her or EAP. Dang!!!!!!
But I'm glad it was EAP who finally got to be mafia after like two years.
Also, thanks for thinking/buying into the idea that I'm good enough to pull a stunt like faking inspector to get CST/Sarah through to the end but I would never try something that risky. I also wouldn't have came out as inspector and given you guys the names of one of the mafia.
Last Edit: Mar 8, 2012 20:41:25 GMT -5 by Deleted - Back to Top
EAP for Mafia Goddess The way you had CST and I so sure of each other was amazing.
I bow to the goddess of Mafia! EAP played day 4 and 5 flawlessly!! She knows i wanted the townies to win and also knows I conceded last night that she was almost certainly going to rule it this game!
awwwww you guys
hahahaha sorry friends!!! truly i couldn't have done it without LD. thank you sir.
i thought it was kind of funny in the end how i was the only one who really believed the real inspector. pretty sure i told phi in a PM, "dude we got the crap end of the stick with SFA as our inspector. he's got your number.".
i have played sooooo many games, i do feel a little proud my second time as mafia i pulled it off.