I received Trillbill's name at the beginning of the game.
I asked about Bek the first night, and she was innocent. I chose to ask about her because of the overlap between her voting record and Trillbill's. So apologies for my confusion last round - I had no Mafia name to go on.
I do now.
My night two ask was Hippie, based on this comment:
so, it's ok for others to feel VERY strongly about their picks without seeming suspicious, but if i am, i'm guilty? not to mention i've said SEVERAL times that i'd be willing to switch my vote if new info came to light.
now i'm just beginning to think the rest of us are being duped. talk about vote-stacking...kel, bek, and kdogg seem to all be pretty adament that those of us who don't agree with them are guilty. i'm thinking that perhaps we DID kill an innocent with trill, and now the mafia are playing us.
i keep my vote for kel, and hope that some of you reconsider, as i think we're all being conned here.
I knew at least two of the three names she suggested as guilty were in fact innocent; she also suggested that Mafia Trillbill was innocent.
She's guilty as sin.
kdogg >>> Hippie
BTW, apologies to you Bek... I had to put out a red herring to suggest someone other than myself was the Inspector. Looks like Mafia took my bait.
I think Bek's voting record will show us that the Mafia thought this was a plausible scenario... which most likely leads us to either Bacon or Higgi. Not sure which, tempted to say Higgi...
I about about tp be without internet. I am hoping the relatives have wireless but if not I will not be here to vote again until Friday afternoon. I'll see if anyone else posts anything in the next hour then I'll make my vote. If it is a runoff between whoever I vote for & someone else then keep my vote with my original vote. Does anyone have any objections/suggestions? If you wanna vote me off that's cool too but if you keep me here until I get back you can be guranteed I'm a townsperson and know you aren't wasting a vote. I'd rather ya'll kill someone you think is mafia.
Hmmm I have no idea what to make of this. First none of the previously killed people appeared to the inspector, but second I don't understand why mafia wouldn't kill kdogg on the first night every time considering he puts far more analysis and thought in this game than anyone else. I am going to trust kdogg ..... for now. Baconus66> Hippie
I have no choice, but to believe Kdogg. Hippie voted Bacon in the run off, and voted me in the run off. Not ever voting Higgi or Trill. She kept babbling about changing her vote, but yet she never did! I call BS.. And lets say Bek was the inspector, she herself said I seem innocent.. very innocent. So, she could have asked about me. And the fact that Hippie defended Higgi so much, makes me think he was mafia, even more now. So, if we kill Hippie and game not over, we go after Bacon or Kdogg tomorrow.
Ok, I am voting Hippie too. #1 Because I have to leave now and must make a vote soon. #2 Because I have been suspicious of her for a while now but have been trying to figure things out. #3 I had a feeling kdogg was inspector a few pages back....but then though he could be in cahoots with Kel. I'm going with him on this one for now. I'll hopefully be back online tomorrow. Fingers crossed that there is internet where I am going. I'll go with Kdogg now but, townspeople, if ya'll suspect any funny business later on I think ya'll should gang up on Bacon & Kdogg, as Mafia.
Ok bye! I will try to be back soon, if not I'll be looking foraward to seeing what happens and sorry if this throws a wrench in the game. Maybe I can at least pop into a Starbucks with my laptop tomorrow and get online Wow, that is pathetic!
What is even more pathetic is that I am stalling leaving the house to play Mafia....and considering calling Verizon tomorrow and adding internet to my phone.....I need help, seriously
You don't have internet on your phone???
Naw! I am old school! I am wondering if I can call after hours and add it or do I have to wait until business hours. The bad thing is I tried getting on inforoo from the husband's phone and it didn't ever get me past the log in page.
I would not be so sure that you will die. If the game continues and you are still alive it makes you look pretty bad.
If I live through the night, it's because the Mafia wants: 1. to bring my credibility into question, and 2. to have you kill me, because them whacking me pretty much confirms what I have to say.
Now, as I said I would, some thoughts on the game after re-reading with the benefit of hindsight.
Everyone remember earlier, when I guaranteed one dead Mafia if we voted both Trillbill & Bacon those first two rounds? I knew I could deliver on that promise.
Remember what I said about Mafia hiding behind reciprocal votes in the first round? That I think Mafia members are more likely to vote against one another early on, rather than with one another? Twice I have been Inspector, twice in the first round I asked about the only player who voted exactly the same as my known Mafia, and twice that person was innocent. So I think we should look at who was reciprocating votes with the two known Mafia: Trillbill & Hippie.
If there really is some kind of Mafia vote-reciprocation scheme going on, I think we'd need to take a look at Bacon & Wolf. Also interesting is that EAP, whose favorite person to vote for regardless of role is Handgunhips, got whacked that night...
In a close vote, both of the known Mafia are trying to get rid of Bacon. Since it appears the Mafia are going after Bacon, and Bek was confirmed innocent, there is one Bacon voter whose status remains in question: Handgunhips
Kel >>> Higgi>>>>Kel>>>>Higgi Higgi >>> Kel kdogg >>> Kel >>> Higgi>>>Kel>>>>Higgi>>>>Null Jen >>> Kel Bek >>> Higgi Bacon >>> Higgi Handgun >>> Kel Hippie >>> Kel Wolf>>>Higgi
Hippie voted for Kel, along with Handgun, Jenkazoo & Higgi. There's Handgun's name again.
Near the end and shortly after that, I started dropping some hints that Bek was Inspector. I wanted to distract the Mafia from the fact that it might be myself. The fact that the Mafia killed Bek shows that her voting record may have made them nervous enough to think she actually was the Inspector. A list of all players for whom Bek voted this game: Bacon (twice in Day One) Higgi (twice in Day Two)
We know we'll only have one Mafia left - if any - after this vote closes... Looking at all of this, I believe Bacon & Handgun appear to be the most likely candidates.
I agree with most of what you say Kdogg but I would like to explain a few of my actions to show my innocence.
Me saying that I was not sure you would be dead was exactly for the reason you said, it makes everything you said seem false and gets you killed.
As for the mafia members voting for me that seems quite easy to explain. If it is true the Hippie, Trill, and Higgi are the mafia that would make me the only non mafia member in the run-off. Even if Higgi was innocent that would make me 1 of 2 innocents in the runoff. For some reason they picked me over Higgi.
As for the people I said were very suspicious I believe I prefaced that post with something along the lines of "this is the most confused I have ever been while playing mafia." After much reading I decided Higgi seemed to be the most suspicious of the group.
I have been growing more and more suspicious of HGH and AWATD. If I were you I would ask about one of them but its up to you. Hopefully Higgi was mafia and all of this is pointless.
I'd be happy to have my named looked at during the next night time that seems to be close to happening if that is where kdogg feels his inspecting will be the most useful. But dogg if I were you I would look out for HGH. It seems like HGH has gone the quiet mafia path and as you pointed out the voting record would seem to suggest HGH being the final mafia member.
Wolf, I think Hippie's efforts to make you look like Mafia suggest your innocence. I see some reasons for suspicion, but I don't really see any collaboration between you and the known Mafia.
Bacon, on the other hand... what the hell is going on? You & Hippie suggested the same four people as being suspect yesterday, before I learned she was Mafia. That looks an awful smurfing lot like you two have the same agenda...
And Handgun... why so quiet? I think you've got the most explaining to catch up on.
Post by handgunhipster on Jul 23, 2009 8:03:00 GMT -5
Like the past couple of games with the Inspector, I encourage Kdogg to ask about me if he's concerned, and it'll come back as Innocent.
I can promise all the townspeople, that I'm innocent. I don't have some awesome explanation as to why I'm innocent, except I'm innocent. I don't know how I'm suspicious for not posting, because I was the same last game and I was innocent- I'm super busy. :[
I vote Hippie.
edit: this only posted half my post. wtf.
basically, the first part of my post was explaining why I don't post, which is because I don't have internet access at work, only via my phone, and it's the last week of my summer semester at school. then I proclaimed my innocence. 100% innocent here.
Post by Fishing Maniac on Jul 23, 2009 10:21:11 GMT -5
Jenkazoo just contacted me to tell you that she "got internet on my phone but it wont let me log in to inforoo. i can read their posts but cannot post my votes. I will have full internet tomorrow and will post." Sent to me on facebook last night.
In my role, I know Night cannot close until I send the Referee my guess. I also know how I want to die, and need to send that in to Roo before my guess. So, I'll have the floor and won't have to yield until I PM my guess. I know I can die without having any unfinished business.
I am, for self-preservation reasons, unable to tell y'all who I intend to ask about tonight. In fact, I haven't quite decided...
I want to hear from you before I send my guess. So, fellow Townspeople and the other one... can I get a straw poll about who you would ask about tonight?