Not a big Phish fan but I love WSP. That being said, I would not want either band, or any specific band for that matter, closing out Bonnaroo every single year. Bonnaroo is about variety not monotony. WSP has closed out Roo alot in the past but to be a little fair they were a substitute one year for Allman Bros due to Gregg Allman dealing with health issues. Phish puts on a good show, it's just not my style of music. I certainly try not to blast other people's music tastes simply because I'm not a fan of the band. If I don't like the band that is playing, I will just go see someone else. If it is the closing band, I'll go an enjoy it anyway. That is what is so great about Roo...choices.