Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Ian, you're logic is laughable. I think that the theory of mafia killing their own to throw off the game is absolutely retarded. There are only THREE mafia, this just does not make any sense what-so-ever. I voted for Hippi cuz I wanted to believe Sadie, but now i can't. That round was taking way too long and it looked like she was dying anyway, so sorry to help vote off your make-believe message board girlfriend, you shmuck. You are shooting in the dark pal, and you don;t know what's going on any better than I do. PLUS, whenever I've accused anyone in this game, I always leave a possibilty that i might be mistaken, where as you are totally convinced that I am "shady no?" Even with Sadie's theory, I entertained that it would be possible with more mafia players but by being only THREE players, it wouldn't be a smart strategy. edit:: Ya damn poogley doo-flob.
it does seem retarded that mafia would kill one of their own, but that may be exactly what they were aiming for... something such as that, which we would never believe. I don't believe or disbelieve this but I do, now, feel like Sadie is telling the truth... We have been through several rounds of this game and no one else has come forward to say they are the inspector.. By all means, the real inspector would come forward.. Because if not, they are just letting someone pretending to be the inspector kill off innocent players.
Maybe the inspector was killed off already. We keep failing to assume this possibility. So what then in Sadie doing? Well she could be mafia, of course thats what we want to believe, but she could also be a townsperson trying to get people whacked that she believes to be guilty. I had thought of trying this earlier in the game but sadie took the opportunity from me.
Pemp, where in my post do I name outright more than 3 people to be mafia? Infact, I only see two, yourself and Higgi. I mention Hippi and Toofast in the post, but never state that I believe them to be mafia.
it does seem retarded that mafia would kill one of their own, but that may be exactly what they were aiming for... something such as that, which we would never believe. I don't believe or disbelieve this but I do, now, feel like Sadie is telling the truth... We have been through several rounds of this game and no one else has come forward to say they are the inspector.. By all means, the real inspector would come forward.. Because if not, they are just letting someone pretending to be the inspector kill off innocent players.
Maybe the inspector was killed off already. We keep failing to assume this possibility. So what then in Sadie doing? Well she could be mafia, of course thats what we want to believe, but she could also be a townsperson trying to get people whacked that she believes to be guilty. I had thought of trying this earlier in the game but sadie took the opportunity from me.
Pemp, where in my post do I name outright more than 3 people to be mafia? Infact, I only see two, yourself and Higgi. I mention Hippi and Toofast in the post, but never state that I believe them to be mafia.
I did consider this, but Sadie started insinuating her role as Inspector quite early.. It wasn't until a few rounds later that she actually came out and said it..
I don't know, determining whether or not she is telling the truth will be the key to us townspeople winning the game.. So I am going to go on her word and hope she isn't playing us, I am sticking with Roo as my vote, and if we vote him off Sadie says the game ends, if the game ends, we win.. if it doesn't we know what we have to do.
Ok, guys. So you may have noticed that Beatles did not vote. I want to apologize if anyone is upset, but please let me explain my reasoning.
Last game, as you may have noticed, the game lasted for FAR longer than it really needed to. Yes, many of the players could be long-winded, but a lot of that stemmed from having the time to do so because players were not participating, thus allowing more time for speculation before they finally voted.
There have been no actual rules laid down as to how to do deal with the situation of a player that is MIA, so for now, this is how I choose to handle it. Everyone's had since Thursday to vote. It is now almost 6pm eastern time, and Beatles has not voted. Not only do I think it's unfair that it holds up the game as a whole, but it can severely skew voting(for both sides) if a player is voting without having been a part of the game, and therefore not really understanding what's going on.
So, for now I'm just closing voting, and her vote will not be counted. What happens after that is up for discussion. Whether someone takes her spot, or she is killed off for lack of a better option. I'm open to suggestions.
Ok, guys. So you may have noticed that Beatles did not vote. I want to apologize if anyone is upset, but please let me explain my reasoning.
Last game, as you may have noticed, the game lasted for FAR longer than it really needed to. Yes, many of the players could be long-winded, but a lot of that stemmed from having the time to do so because players were not participating, thus allowing more time for speculation before they finally voted.
There have been no actual rules laid down as to how to do deal with the situation of a player that is MIA, so for now, this is how I choose to handle it. Everyone's had since Thursday to vote. It is now almost 6pm eastern time, and Beatles has not voted. Not only do I think it's unfair that it holds up the game as a whole, but it can severely skew voting(for both sides) if a player is voting without having been a part of the game, and therefore not really understanding what's going on.
So, for now I'm just closing voting, and her vote will not be counted. What happens after that is up for discussion. Whether someone takes her spot, or she is killed off for lack of a better option. I'm open to suggestions.
I agree completely with your decision to close voting.
I also think that players should think twice before joining in a game that they can't actively participate in. Maybe said players should sit out a game or two if they can't participate. Rather than continue to sign up, and continue to hold up voting. I tried to enact a time limit last game, but it didn't work so well.
I don't think she should be replaced. If she is a role player, that would be unfair.
it does seem retarded that mafia would kill one of their own, but that may be exactly what they were aiming for... something such as that, which we would never believe. I don't believe or disbelieve this but I do, now, feel like Sadie is telling the truth... We have been through several rounds of this game and no one else has come forward to say they are the inspector.. By all means, the real inspector would come forward.. Because if not, they are just letting someone pretending to be the inspector kill off innocent players.
Maybe the inspector was killed off already. We keep failing to assume this possibility. So what then in Sadie doing? Well she could be mafia, of course thats what we want to believe, but she could also be a townsperson trying to get people whacked that she believes to be guilty. I had thought of trying this earlier in the game but sadie took the opportunity from me.
Pemp, where in my post do I name outright more than 3 people to be mafia? Infact, I only see two, yourself and Higgi. I mention Hippi and Toofast in the post, but never state that I believe them to be mafia.
i agree with just about everything you say. although i am fairly certain sadie is guilty. she stated she KNEW i was guilty, therefore i can't believe that she is innocent. therefore, i would say sadie and 2 of the3 (sirpem, higgi, toofast).i say we go after higgi or sirpem next round.
I'm curious, what makes you guys think I am guilty? Because, clearly, all I have done throughout this game is try to uncover the mafia, and do believe I have been very fair with my voting... I mean, I didn't even cast a random vote first round, I voted for myself for goodness sake.
I am very confident that our mafia lies within the Sadie/Roo battle. As I've mentioned before, when we figure out what is going on here, ie who's lying. We'll be on the right track.
I have decided that the smartest thing to do right now is take Sadie's word for truth.. We vote off Roo and if the game doesn't end it's simple.. Sadie is mafia, and this will lead to her accomplices..
p.s. if i was mafia, and claimed NBF to be mafia then... why (as mafia) would i kill her over night? that makes no sense at all. it makes me look bad. it comes right out and shows i was making false accusations. you understand what i'm saying?
you are all being fooled. killing me was a bad idea.
Sadie was riding shotgun in a friend's vehicle alongside I-24, waiting to get inside Bonnaroo. Nature called, and she had to answer. She got out of the car in ran into a wooded area alongside the highway to do her business. The line started to move, and Sadie's friend had no choice but to move with it, thinking she would be able to catch up to the slow-moving line... but Sadie was never heard from again.
I'm curious, what makes you guys think I am guilty? Because, clearly, all I have done throughout this game is try to uncover the mafia, and do believe I have been very fair with my voting... I mean, I didn't even cast a random vote first round, I voted for myself for goodness sake.
I am very confident that our mafia lies within the Sadie/Roo battle. As I've mentioned before, when we figure out what is going on here, ie who's lying. We'll be on the right track.
I have decided that the smartest thing to do right now is take Sadie's word for truth.. We vote off Roo and if the game doesn't end it's simple.. Sadie is mafia, and this will lead to her accomplices..
the problem with your plan is that if you vote me off, the townspeople lose.
Higgi Sirpem\ Roocon Ian PimpMcGeorge Beatles
there are 6 players left. most likely 4 townspeople, 2 mafia (with sadie 3rd mafia). mafia kills 1 tonight. now 3 townspeopl, 2 mafia. if you vote me off, 2 townspeople, 2 mafia. then the mafia whacks somebody. 1 townsp, 2 mafia. game over.
we can't make a mistake from here out. if we make 1 wrong move, we lose.
As far as Beatles, I don't think it's unfair to close the vote as long as it was open for at least 24 hours & a reasonable effort was made to contact her.
Post by rooconteur on Apr 21, 2009 18:58:40 GMT -5
i think we need to start looking at beatles as possible mafia. kel has had to wait very long for pm's all game. she has been around the least and lost her vote last round. this makes me think kel is waiting for her. that makes her either inspector or mafia. it makes sense that she could be inspector. she didnt stand up to sadie because she hasnt been around, maybe. i dont know for sure. but id bet shes either mafia or inspector.
Friday night at Bonnaroo, Ian goes to the Phish late night. Ian was feeling good and really going eaten some heady corn, but responsibly. About an hour in, somebody sneaks by and slips some corn in his drink. The same corn he was eating, but this was now way more than he could handle. Another hour later, during a funky Phish jam/crazy light section, Ian has a seizure, swallows his tongue and dies.
i think we need to start looking at beatles as possible mafia. kel has had to wait very long for pm's all game. she has been around the least and lost her vote last round. this makes me think kel is waiting for her. that makes her either inspector or mafia. it makes sense that she could be inspector. she didnt stand up to sadie because she hasnt been around, maybe. i dont know for sure. but id bet shes either mafia or inspector.
Maybe I haven't been playing mafia long enough, but I have a hard time believing that Beatles was actually the inspector and Sadie got away with claiming to be inspector herself. Even if Beatles was just glancing at the thread, she'd have to see at least some of what Sadie was saying. After all, she went on and on about being the inspector quite a bit. But Beatles being mafia does make a lot more sense, considering she's already shown that she's willing to vote to eliminate someone who already was leading the group in votes (Hippi, if I remember correctly). If I were in the mafia and didn't have a whole lot of time to follow the thread, I would definitely just vote to ensure that a townsperson was eliminated whenever I could. I said it before and damnit I'll say it again, I vote for Beatles...at least tentatively.
6/18: Phish in Hartford 6/25: Phish in Camden 7/2-7/4: Nateva 7/17: God Street Wine at Irving Plaza 7/23-7/25: String Cheese at Red Rocks!! 8/17-8/18: Phish at Jones Beach 9/3: Rush at PNC
This Bonnaroo lineup is in dire need of some Rush.
Post by Ian'sGotAFeeling on Apr 22, 2009 0:52:37 GMT -5
You know what?! I am in a place with free corn now people! I think you should all hit the crazy train with me and let yourselves get killed! Cause its coming!
i believe sadie was our real inspector. i think that she told us the mafia and because it is so easy we all found it too hard to believe... I vote for Roo.